Today we’re talking about something from Willett that caught me by surprise: the 4-Year Bourbon Purple Top. Yes, it’s a purple top, but not the thousand-dollar showpiece your buddy posts once a year. This one’s aiming to be the more “affordable” everyday version. I grabbed mine for $69 at an allocation drop (shoutout to The Wine Barrel in Edmond, Oklahoma), and for a Willett at barrel proof? That’s worth a closer look.
Willett: A Wild Ride
Willett, as a brand, is just inconsistent. When it misses, it really misses—some of that weird funky profile just doesn’t sit right. But when it lands, especially with those older age-stated purple tops, it can be near perfect. I’ve never been big on their Pot Still bottle, Noah’s Mill, or Rowan’s Creek—those just don’t do it for me. This 4-year, though? Barrel proof, fresh take, and not trying to ride the same wave as the older stuff. Let’s get into it.
First Impressions
Color’s a bright golden amber. It’s young, so I wasn’t expecting anything too dark, but it shows well in the glass. The legs hang around, which already gives some hope for texture.
On the Nose
Right away, it sets itself apart from some of Willett’s more polarizing pours. No musty or sour notes here. What you do get is a hit of rye spice, honey, apple, maybe even a touch of clove. It’s bright, inviting, and has a nice balance between sweetness and spice.
Taste and Finish
It drinks like a 126+ proof bottle should—there’s heat, but it’s controlled. You get that rye right up front, then it softens into maple syrup, baking spice, and just a hint of that signature Willett funk (but it’s dialed way down). Honey and toffee sneak in mid-palate. The finish is long and rich, with cinnamon and toasted oak hanging on in a way that keeps you coming back. Honestly, it’s got more depth than I expected for a 4-year release.
Final Thoughts
This bottle isn’t trying to be the older purple tops—it’s carving out its own space. And for something you can actually find at allocation drops or on shelves here and there, it does a lot of things right. At $69, it feels like a steal when you consider what else is out there at barrel proof in this age range.
Score: 84/100.
Factoring in the price, availability (which is getting better), and flavor profile—it’s a strong showing from a brand that doesn’t always play it safe.
Summary
- Proof: 126.6
- Age: 4 years
- Price: ~$69
- Flavor: Maple, rye spice, honey, clove
- Finish: Long, sweet, and a little spicy
- Verdict: A surprisingly refined pour from a brand known for extremes
If you spot it, it’s absolutely worth picking up. For once, Willett gave us something strong, tasty, and relatively accessible. Let’s hope it sticks around.
